nice editorial..

Editorial: Feting pluralism in Ramadhan

The Jakarta Post Fri, July 20 2012,


There is no better theme to celebrate during this year’s Ramadhan than pluralism. The fact that Muslims in Indonesia are widely divided about when the holy fasting month begins is both a symbol and a reminder of the pluralism that exists among the millions of adherents to Islam in this country.

We seem to have this debate every year: either about the start of Ramadhan or about when it ends. In many instances, Muhammadiyah and Nahdlatul Ulama (NU), the country’s two largest Muslim organizations, are at opposite ends of the spectrum. The government is inevitably caught between them. Although the Religious Affairs Ministry hosts annual meetings to determine when Ramadhan begins and ends by consensus, it has to respect the differences that often emerge, including between NU and Muhammadiyah.

Many Muslims are bewildered if not confused by the debate that we seem to have year in and year out. Some ask why can’t these two Muslim organizations agree on matters as “inconsequential” as the start or end of Ramadhan.

Many understandably decide to follow the government. Others trust their respective organizations, be they NU, Muhammadiyah or other smaller groups and sects. Once Ramadhan begins, however, the debate stops and everyone goes about his or her own affairs. Everyone respects other groups’ decisions, until the next disagreement.

That’s precisely the beauty of pluralism, which is very much alive within Islam, and most likely in all other religions that exist in this country.

“There shall be no coercion in matters of faith,” Muslims are repeatedly told in the Koran. Believe what you want to believe. Another popular verse says, “Unto you your faith; unto me, mine,” which is another way of saying that you should respect my belief as I yours. There can be no clearer illustrations than these verses that pluralism defines Islam.

No other country in the world with a predominantly Muslim population goes through heated debates about the beginning and end of Ramadhan. Most of these countries, such as those in the Middle East and North Africa and also including Bangladesh, Malaysia, Brunei and Pakistan, are Islamic states by definition or by constitution. In these countries, the state defines religion. It makes religious rulings, which everyone is expected to follow. No one, or very few, would argue with the government about when Ramadhan starts.

Indonesia may be the country with the world’s largest Muslim population, but it is not an Islamic state. The state has no final say in matters of faith. Even the fatwa of the Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI) are not binding. Everyone is free to believe what they want to believe. And with NU, Muhammadiyah, and other organizations and sects (and we can throw in Ahmadiyah and Shia), people have a choice about which one they want to follow. Everybody, including the state, must respect individual choices.

The debate about the start and end of Ramadhan is a reflection of the plurality of Islam in Indonesia, while the respect that people extend to the choices of others underpins the freedom that religious adherents in this country enjoy, as they rightly should.

Celebrating pluralism this Ramadhan would be particularly timely since there have been signs of late of rising intolerance among people of different religions.

Followers of Ahmadiyah and Shia have been the targets of violent attacks because of their faith. Christians, the largest religious minority group, have felt the heat also, with many being prevented from building houses of worship. In almost all instances of religious intolerance, Muslims or those professing to act for Islam are the culprits.

This year’s Ramadhan would therefore be a good time for Muslims, who make up about 88 percent of the Indonesian population, to reflect on the events of the past year. Religious intolerance does not define Islam, and every decent Muslim must fight this.

With Ramadhan beginning, everyone — Muslims and non-Muslims alike — need to recommit themselves to
the values of pluralism, for it defines Indonesia and it defines Islam.