Cancer again ?

Govt plans levy on sweetened, carbonated drinks


The Jakarta Post, Jakarta Wed, December 12 2012,

In an attempt to control the consumption of sweetened, carbonated beverages, the government is planning to impose a levy on the drinks which, if consumed, are believed to negatively impact people’s health.

Finance Ministry fiscal agency interim head Bambang Brodjonegoro said in Jakarta on Tuesday that consumption of sweetened, carbonated beverages needed to be controlled because of health concerns.

“Based on the report compiled by the National Drug and Food Monitoring Agency (BPOM), excessive consumption of sweetened, carbonated drinks can damage the kidneys, increase the risk of diabetes, trigger uric acid, disturb the functions of the stomach, liver, intestine and cause obesity,” Bambang told legislators during a hearing with the House of Representatives’ Commission XI overseeing finance and banking.

Due to the potentially damaging health impacts of carbonated sweet drinks, Bambang said that the consumption of the drinks should then be imposed using a levy scheme as an instrument.

“Philosophically speaking, imposing a levy on sweetened, carbonated drinks is in line with Law No. 39/2007 on levies,” Bambang said.

Bambang added that imposing a levy on carbonated drinks to control excessive consumption was common practice in at least 79 countries, so Indonesia should follow suit.

“Even the US, which is the main producer of carbonated drinks, applies a levy on the product,” he said.

Another reason considered by the government to impose the levy was the fact that the market share of carbonated sweet drinks in the soft drink industry was still relatively small but yet managed to post a significant amount of sales, according to Bambang.

Based on data from the Association of Soft Drink Manufacturers (ASRIM), sweetened, carbonated drinks accounted for only 3.8 percent of the country’s beverage market in 2011, far below bottled water with an 84 percent share. Regardless of the small market share, sweetened, carbonated drink sales in that year reached a total of Rp 10 trillion (US$1.03 billion), while bottled water reached Rp 18 trillion.

“This data shows that there’s still a lot of room for the growth of sweetened, carbonated drink consumption in the future and this also hints at the large potential for a levy to be collected,” Bambang said.

According to Bambang, the government was currently analyzing five levy schemes, ranging between Rp 1,000 per liter to Rp 5,000 per liter, on sweetened, carbonated drinks, the consumption of which was estimated to be around 790 million liters in 2012.

Based on the consumption rate and the schemes, Bambang said that the government could collect at least Rp 790 billion to Rp 3.95 trillion from the levy each year.

One of the commission’s deputy chairmen, Andi Timo Pangerang from the Democratic Party, said that legislators agreed with the government’s idea to impose a levy on the drinks but added that further assessments and deliberations were required to ensure the policy would not heavily burden both consumers and industrial players.

If the proposal is approved, the drinks will become the country’s third targeted levy, after tobacco and alcoholic drinks.

Indonesian Food and Beverage Association (GAPMMI) chairman Adhie S. Lukman said that industrial players objected to the idea and urged the government to annul it.

“Unlike tobacco and alcohol, carbonated drinks do not pose a severe threat to health,” Adhie said.

“The government should have attempted to provide more incentives to push the industry to grow so that more taxes can be collected. Therefore, we officially reject this levy proposal on carbonated drinks,” he added.

pajak, pajak,pajak
uang,uang,uang


DK

The Jakarta Post, Tue, December 18 2012,


A claim recently made by the government that carbonated drinks pose risks to human health is baseless and has misled the public, the Association of Soft Drink Manufacturers (Asrim) says.

“Our conclusion is that carbonated beverages, unlike cigarettes and alcoholic drinks, do not pose negative risks to human health and therefore should not be taxed,” Asrim secretary-general Suroso Natakusuma said at a press briefing in Jakarta on Monday.

The Finance Ministry revealed in a meeting with the House of Representatives last week that it was considering imposing a levy of between Rp 1,000 (11 US cents) and Rp 5,000 on sweetened, carbonated beverages.

A report compiled by the National Drug and Food Monitoring Agency (BPOM) showed that excessive consumption of such drinks poses risks to human health, causing damage to the kidneys, intestines and liver, as well as increasing the risk of diabetes and causing obesity, said the Finance Ministry’s fiscal agency interim head, Bambang Brodjonegoro.

“That’s misleading,” said Suroso, claiming that the report was “nonsense” made public to justify the government’s intention to earn more tax revenue.

Asrim also lashed out at the government’s claims that the consumption of carbonated drinks in the country had become excessive.

According to Asrim data, consumption of carbonated drinks per capita in Indonesia was only 2.4 liters per person per year. The figure was among the lowest in the region, lagging behind China (10 liters), Malaysia (19 liters), Singapore (31 liters), Thailand (32 liters) and the Philippines (34 liters), according to Asrim data.

Asrim urged the government to reconsider taxing the products. He said imposing a Rp 3,000 levy, for example, would decrease demand by about 25 percent.

Asrim noted that sweetened, carbonated drinks accounted for only 3.8 percent of the country’s beverage market in 2011, far below bottled water with an 84 percent share.
Total sales of sweetened, carbonated drinks topped Rp 10 trillion ($1.03 billion) last year.

Speaking at the press briefing, Bogor Agricultural University (IPB) health expert Made Astawan said the level of caffeine, glucose and caffeine contained in carbonated beverages were still within safe and tolerable limits.

The glucose level in carbonated drink stands at 27 milligrams, not much different to packaged milk (17 milligrams), he said.